I enjoyed Gaiman's preface, in which he described the inspiration for each of the selections and I returned to this section repeatedly.
I always enjoy reading Gaiman's poems, but I rarely remember any of them 24 hours after reading them. Not so, with his short stories - many of these stay with me for years. A favourite theme of Gaiman's is to take an existing story and twist its perspective or to mimic the style of an existing author. He does both in these stories, paying homage to H.P. Lovecraft, Michael Moorcock, the Brothers Grimm.
Although I did not love every story in this volume, I cannot say that I hated any of them. All were worth reading. A few of the stories appeared in Gaiman's "M is for Magic" collection, which was published later, but which I read previously.
Below are my favourite stories from this collection.
A story about an old lady, who finds the Holy Grail in a thrift shop. Shortly after, Sir Galahad approaches to attempt to purchase the relic.
Shoggoth's Old Peculiar
A humorous H.P. Lovecraft mystery
We Can Get Them for You Wholesale
A terrifying story about a man, who seeks volume discounts when hiring an assassin
An angel is murdered in Heaven and another angel is charged with finding his murderer and avenging his death.
Snow, Glass, Apples
A version of Snow White in which the stepmother is the victim and Snow is the villain.
The Goldfish Pool and Other Stories
A hopeful English screenwriter tries to navigate Hollywood's facade.